By Stan Friedman
CHICAGO, IL (August 17, 2011) – A recent decision by the 2nd Circuit Court of Appeals in New York has re-ignited discussion on the constitutionality of public schools renting their facilities to churches.
Roughly 50 percent of the nearly 110 current Evangelical Covenant Church plants meet in public schools, says Peter Sung, director of church planting in the Department of Church Growth and Evangelism. Other congregations have continued to meet in schools or rent other facilities due, in large part, to high costs of construction and maintaining a building.
Schools provide “an ideal space” for churches, Sung says. Rent generally is low, and the schools already have classrooms and auditoriums. Also, newcomers often feel safer going to church in a school rather than a church building.
Churches are the primary renters of schools because Muslims and Jews worship on Fridays and Saturdays, when school space often is used, according to a recent USA Today report.
The 2-1 court ruling issued June 2 upheld the New York City Board of Education’s policy that forbids schools from renting to religious congregations except during the school year. As a result, New York City officials have said churches meeting in public schools must find other meeting space when the school year ends.
The court’s decision stems from a case involving the Bronx House of Faith, which has met in a public school. It is constructing its own building, but the facility will not be ready by the end of the school year.
The decision overturned a 2002 lower court ruling that allowed the Bronx House of Faith and 60 other churches to conduct worship services in school buildings.
The majority opinion in the recent decision cited the First Amendment’s Establishment Clause and stated that it is “reasonable for the board to fear that allowing schools to be converted into churches might foster an excessive government entanglement with religion that advances religion.”
The court’s decision is not binding on other areas of the country and is contrary to other rulings in similar cases. Legal experts expect the U.S. Supreme Court eventually will decide the issue.
“From a legal perspective, I think the issues raised in opposition to churches in school are flimsy at best, says Rob Hall, vice president of Real Estate Services for National Covenant Properties. “Most court rulings state that simply renting to a group is not an endorsement of religion or a religious group’s mission.”
Sung says some Covenant churches have been forced to end their meetings at public schools. “They don’t give religion as the reason – they’re just priced out.” At times, local residents have voiced their displeasure that a church was allowed to meet in a school.
Policies on whether a school or the local board of education decides whether to rent to a church differ from district to district, says Sung. So also do the reasons schools give for whatever decisions they make.
“It ranges from ‘This is a Christian nation so you can use the school’ to ‘You’re a church . . . no way can you meet here,’ ” Sung says.
Sung, who has planted several congregations, says his last church, Queenswest Church in Long Island, New York, was turned down by seven schools before finding one that would rent to them.
Categories:
News
When we began planting Community Covenant Church in West Peabody, Massachusetts, in the fall of 1969, we met in the John F. Kennedy Jr. High School which was located across the road from the property on which we were going to be building our church facility. The relationship with the school was one of mutual benefit. I asked the principal if there was any way we could be of help to the school and he took me up on my offer. He gave me a list of several families whose child or children were attending the school who were in special need. We were able to assist these families during the whole time their children attended the Kennedy school, even after we’d moved into our own church facility. During one conversation I had with the principal, he said that he thought having the name “Community” in our church name was very appropriate. If we had not been meeting at the Kennedy school, I doubt very much if we would have had the opportuniy we did to serve those families in that community who really needed someone’s help. A church meeting in a school need not be a one-way street.
There is a big difference between prohibiting “schools from renting to religious congregations except during the school year” and courts not allowing churches to rent space at all. The article includes both perspectives, and reads a little confusing. The New York City Board of Education ruling sounds like a logistic decision – no renting when the building isn’t in normal use. This is very different from a Constitutional argument saying no renting a public facility because you are religious movement that advances religion.